
So, I am working on a piece for my freelance writing job, one that normally has me compose all manner of entries--essays, biographies, thought-pieces on a theme, etc.--and it dawns on me how damn hard my job can be. It's not the history, so much, that gets me, it is undoing the popular schlock that too many people take for history. If asked to name the one example people in my field (medieval Europe) hate to deal with many of us would say "the Templars." As luck would have it, I am writing a 1500 word "who were they and why are they important" on them this week, and while easy enough to do on the one hand, the amount of space I must devote to counteracting all the garbage about them out there, while not difficult to do, is annoying on the other.
What puzzles me most is why so many people fail to find their actual history interesting--it is not a story that needs embellishing. One of my closest friends is an expert on the Templars, the poor bastard, and as frustrated as I can be explaining how they have nothing to do with early Christian gnosticism, legends of the Holy Grail, Mary Magdalene, or space ships, he must suffer ten times as much. The scary thing, and this is my point, is that so many people buy the lie. The reason is simple enough--they want to believe it. The evidence, such as it is, linking these monastic knights to various occult ideas consists largely of 18th and 19th Romantic fabrications and inventions, and yet, how are people to know that if bookstores (yes I'm talking to you Borders and B&N) only carry the "Telurian" crap? Where are Malcom Barber's various works? Where Partner's _The Murdered Magicians_, an entire chapter of which easily deflates the pseudo-history of _Holy Blood, Holy Grail_?
Then there is the basic historical narrative, its logic, which no one applies. Jerusalem had been an important city, and thus a juicy prize, from early on, so what are the chances that Sesac in 976 B.C., the Romans in A.D. 70 , the Muslims in 636, and the knights of the first Crusade in 1099, to name only a few, failed to loot the place adequately? The Romans under Titus sacked the Temple and the Arch of Titus is full of images of them carrying away loot, so... really, um, how do you figure so many armies failed for a thousand years to divest the Temple of its goodies? Silly.
I will not even address, as it is simply too stupid, the idea of a Church-wide conspiracy to hush up a "blood-line" of Christ that somehow made it to France. One look at any Church council will dispel immediately the notion that the college of bishops could agree on much of anything let alone foment a giant conspiracy. And yet here too people would rather look to gnostic sources outside their context than to a far larger body of contemporary evidence. One sad outcome of this is that good questions can drown in the mix. For example, was Jesus married? Good question, and one that makes sense to ask given what we know of Hebrew culture. He may have been, it would figure, and yet that would affect nothing. Christians can still have the Incarnation and Resurrection with a married Jesus.
Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed _The Da Vinci Code_ as much as anyone who likes a nice little mystery, but no matter how skillfully Brown weaves together various crackpot ideas it isn't history.
